- §2 now a two-rig table: 4090/Qwen-27B-Q4_K_XL/llama.cpp (isolated) vs
3090/Hermes-8B-FP8-Dynamic/vLLM (live/public). Spells out that the
cross-model rate gap confounds FOUR variables (params, quant/precision,
engine, GPU) — not '8B vs 27B' alone.
- §5.4 hermes results under live traffic. Method finding: the watt_bench
window integral is unusable on a contended card, but the slope
calibration survives clean (cancels the variable shared-load baseline)
— so on shared/public cards use watt_calibrate, not the window integral.
Rates: hermes 0.109/4.40 J/tok vs qwen 0.175/6.16; decode 35-40x prefill.
- Per-query DOLLARS both rigs @$0.33/kWh: a grounded substrate answer is
<$0.10 per 1000 queries (hermes $0.085, qwen $0.158); hermes ~half qwen.
- §5.2 budget confound corrected to flag Hermes-tuning honestly (was
rationalized). §9: fixed-budget apples-to-apples re-run + per-model
budget tuning added as next steps.
russell@unturf.com
b44e9255b2