Today's warrant-lite (aborist/qa/warrant.py) covers two anchor
classes: proper-noun (relation-shape questions) and date (any
claim with a 4-digit year). Three failure shapes pass the existing
seven hard checks unchecked:
- entity-list: 'name the simpsons family + pets' — claim
enumerates entities, but the warrant doesn't demand all named
entities appear in some cited span.
- count: 'how many wives did henry the eighth have?' — claim
says 'six', but the warrant doesn't demand the count token
appear in some cited span.
- why-cause: 'why did the titanic sink?' — claim names a cause
noun (iceberg, asteroid, propaganda), but the warrant doesn't
demand the cause token appear in some cited span.
Ticket proposes per-shape anchor extractors dispatched by question-
shape detector (existing _question_is_relation_shape pattern).
Conservative scope on cause anchors: gate by why-shape only since
lowercase common-noun extraction has higher false-positive risk.
Folds into governance_policy_hash via per-class policy dict so an
operator can disable individual classes per-corpus when they
over-fire.
Out of scope per docs/naming-deferral.md: typed-contract framework
(per-question-type rule libraries). General anchor-class primitive
catches the failures listed without per-type rule books; typed
contracts earn slots only when bench evidence shows the general
primitive misses cases.
Forecast cost ~3-4 hours; risk medium (false-positive risk on
why-shape cause-noun extraction). Closes the lazy-anchor gap on
the question shapes the bench question set already exercises.
russell@unturf.com
b5f7c93fca