Built bench/fixtures/5f/relevance-miscite-realcontext-v1.jsonl —
20 hand-crafted (claim, source) mis-cite pairs: claim about X, source
about Y, X≠Y but shared tokens. Each pair survives the lexical
title-relevance + verifier sidecars by construction. This is the
Zionist-entity failure mode (claim about a different entity than the
cited source, both lexically related).
Examples:
- 'Mercury is the smallest planet' / Roman-god Mercury source
- 'Java is a programming language' / Java-the-island source
- 'Apple Inc. was co-founded by Steve Jobs' / apple-the-fruit source
- 'The Eiffel Tower is in Paris' / Gustave-Eiffel-person source
- 'Mozart composed The Magic Flute' / Mozart-effect-theory source
Headline (bge-reranker-large + cleaned + θ ≤ -2.42):
Mis-cite catch: 20/20 = 100% ← FULL COVERAGE of motivating shape
Deflection catch: 11/20 = 55%
Combined NEG: 31/40 = 78%
Real-STRICT FP: 0/808 = 0% ← strictly safe
bge-large mis-cite scores: -9.37 to -3.81 (max). STRICT min: -2.42.
Mis-cite is STRICTLY SEPARABLE from real STRICT — there's a 1.4-pt
gap with no overlap. (Deflection harder; some overlap with weak STRICT.)
MiniLM-L-6 cost-pick (5× smaller, cleaned, θ=+3):
100% mis-cite + 65% deflect + 0.4% STRICT FP
Mis-cite is structurally MUCH easier than deflection — both models
hit 95-100% mis-cite catch at modest θ; deflection is harder because
'answer doesn't quite address question' can look like a weak STRICT.
That's appropriate: mis-cite is 'wrong topic entirely'; deflection
is 'right topic, not answering'.
Manifest:
- runtime_viability flipped (step 2 → step 3): NOT VIABLE → VIABLE
at the bge-large fp=0 operating point.
- demote_below_score still null pending fox+dav1d sign-off (setting
it folds relevance_policy_hash into governance_policy_hash per
#000049 §7 #2).
- PRIMARY RECOMMENDATION: bge-reranker-large + cleaned +
θ ≤ -2.42 → 100% mis-cite, 55% deflect, 0% STRICT FP.
Production verifier unchanged; still SHADOW. The §3.2 arc went:
candidate-bench (overclaim) → real STRICT step 2 (over-pessimistic
NOT VIABLE) → real-context deflection step 3 (positive reversal,
55% at fp=0) → real-context mis-cite step 3 part B (full closure
at fp=0 for the motivating failure mode). Eight meta-lesson
instances over the §000049 + §000052 arc, with the sharpest one
yet: clean candidate-bench can mis-predict in BOTH directions —
real-data fixtures on BOTH precision and recall axes are the
only load-bearing measurement.
russell@unturf.com
902e676d4d