Timestamp: 2026-06-01, Asia/Kuala_Lumpur
Subject: final regenerated response to `#000070 — Spatial-anchor π*_w_object / AnchorN / axiom-governed world-state substrate`

# 0. Final verdict

```text
#000070 — GO, but rewrite it before implementation.

Corrected decision:
    GO for a generic AnchorN substrate primitive.
    GO for Joseph6 as the first registered default grammar.
    GO for deterministic object-state canonicalization.
    GO for axiom/physics-loaded WorldDimensionGrammar as the scalable path.

    NO-GO for hard-coding H₁..H₆ as the final ontology.
    NO-GO for runtime LLM-decided dimensionality.
    NO-GO for calling this a semantic verifier warrant.
    NO-GO for relation/event/place/agent_trace inside the first object ticket.
    NO-GO for SQL persistence in Phase 1.
```

The earlier `H₁..H₆` design is useful as a first executable kernel:

```text
H₁ = position seed
H₂ = scale seed
H₃ = rotation seed
H₄ = material seed
H₅ = relation seed
H₆ = behavior seed
```

But your latest correction is right: **six fixed fields should not be treated as the final ontology of world-state.** The stronger architecture is:

```text
hard hash + seed + frozen world grammar
→ AnchorN region split
→ N typed dimension mappers
→ canonical world-state record
→ Merkle/SHA-256 commitment
```

Where `N` is not chosen by vibes, prompt text, or model drift. `N` is selected by a **frozen, versioned, axiom-constrained WorldDimensionGrammar**.

That preserves determinism while allowing geometry, counting, temporal order, relations, and physics constraints to emerge naturally as committed substrate dimensions rather than as latent LLM impressions.

---

# 1. Current ground truth from Arborist docs

The public Arborist docs already define v7-W as the spatial-temporal substrate for committed derived world-state, sister to v7 logic/math and Arborist language/claim-lattice. It commits objects, relations, events, places, agent traces, and observations, and says each tuple class has a canonical projection `π*_w` whose canonical bytes hash to an equivalence-class identity. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

The v7-W hard constraints are exactly the right constraints for #000070: stay inside canonical encoding, public quantization, and collision-resistant hashing; every `π*_w` is defined over quantized integer state, not continuous tensors; and the grid/frame/clock choices are part of the commitment. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

The current π* library also confirms the architectural rule: each modality that touches the bench or audit chain needs a registered `π*` mapping surface bytes to canonical bytes, and SHA-256 of those canonical bytes becomes the equivalence-class identity. It also states that registered `name@version` entries are behaviorally immutable and byte-affecting changes require a new version key. ([Arborist API Reference][2])

The cache discipline matters too: Arborist’s cache key includes source root, question hash, model profile hash, conversation hash, governance policy hash, schema version, canonicalization version, and chunking version, and bumping any dimension creates a distinct cache key. ([Arborist API Reference][3]) The concepts page also says the optional 9th verifier-policy dimension exists for audit legibility, while verifier-policy fields are already covered under governance policy by default. ([Arborist API Reference][4])

So #000070 must be implemented as a **canonicalization / world-state projection** ticket first, not as a new verifier or audit-mode ticket.

---

# 2. Do we already have #000070?

```text
Partially.

Already present:
    v7-W paper and world-state tuple taxonomy.
    π* registry discipline.
    canonicalization-version discipline.
    Merkle/SHA-256 commitment model.
    hard/soft proof-path separation.
    time-series-quantized@v1 and math π* precedent.
    metacognition, DAG, run provenance, cache invalidation.
    broader Merkle-AGI-DAG-Reverse-RAG / SQD / CTI / PROMETHEUS-Σ architecture.

Missing:
    executable π*_w_object kernel.
    generic AnchorN splitter.
    Joseph6 as first registered world grammar.
    WorldDimensionGrammar manifest.
    grammar_hash and axiom_pack_hash.
    axiom/physics-constrained grammar selection.
    spatial_anchor_seed manifest field.
    KATs for world-object canonicalization.
    relation/event/place/agent_trace kernels.
```

So the clean answer is:

```text
We have the conceptual substrate.
We do not yet have the executable state-space instantiation kernel.
```

#000070 should be the first implementation ticket that moves v7-W from paper/scaffold into runnable deterministic substrate code.

---

# 3. Core correction: replace fixed Anchor6 with generic AnchorN

The original six-region design is not wrong. It is a good **default grammar**. But it is too brittle as the substrate primitive.

## 3.1 Old model

```text
hash → H₁..H₆ → position, scale, rotation, material, relation, behavior
```

This is easy to implement and easy to test. But it assumes every object-like state should be decomposed into exactly six dimensions.

That fails for richer world-state.

A rigid body may need:

```text
position
orientation
scale
velocity
angular_velocity
mass
material
collision_shape
```

A field object may need:

```text
support_region
field_type
amplitude
gradient
boundary_condition
time_evolution
```

A temporal event may need:

```text
t_start
t_end
participants
place
causal_preconditions
causal_effects
confidence
```

A social/legal/institutional object may need:

```text
agent_id
role
permission
obligation
counterparty
jurisdiction
time_window
evidence_root
```

So the primitive should not be `Anchor6`.

## 3.2 Correct model

```text
AnchorN = deterministic split of a hard commitment into N typed dimension seeds.
```

Formal object:

```text
Given:
    H = 32-byte hard hash
    S = 32-byte spatial_anchor_seed
    G = frozen WorldDimensionGrammar
    N = len(G.dimensions)

Compute:
    R = HMAC_SHA512_expand(S, H, 32N)

Split:
    R = D₁ || D₂ || ... || D_N
    where each Dᵢ is 32 bytes

Map:
    fieldᵢ = mapperᵢ(Dᵢ, G, manifest)

Canonicalize:
    W = canonical_json({
        pi_star_ref,
        grammar_hash,
        axiom_pack_hash,
        seed_hash,
        hard_hash,
        fields
    })

Commit:
    world_object_hash = SHA256(W)
```

Then Joseph’s six slots become:

```text
Joseph6 = first registered WorldDimensionGrammar
```

not the final ontology.

---

# 4. Corrected ticket title

The current ticket should become:

```text
#000070 — AnchorN and π*_w_object: deterministic world-object canonicalization
```

Optional subtitle:

```text
Phase 1: Joseph6 default grammar over generic AnchorN
```

This title prevents conceptual lock-in.

---

# 5. Corrected direct answer to your latest intuition

Your intuition:

```text
“Load it with maths and physics axioms and let it decide how many.”
```

Correct version:

```text
Load a frozen axiom/physics pack.
Generate or select a candidate WorldDimensionGrammar.
Validate it deterministically.
Freeze its grammar_hash.
Then AnchorN uses that frozen grammar to decide N.
```

Unsafe version:

```text
Ask an LLM at runtime how many dimensions to use.
```

That breaks reproducibility.

Safe version:

```text
LLM may propose grammar candidates.
Only deterministic validators can accept them.
Accepted grammar is canonicalized, hashed, KAT-tested, and versioned.
```

So yes, your direction is better, but only with a hard boundary:

```text
Axioms may select the grammar.
The grammar must be frozen before proof-path use.
```

---

# 6. Axiom-governed WorldDimensionGrammar

## 6.1 What a grammar is

A `WorldDimensionGrammar` is a deterministic manifest that says:

```text
For this object/event/world-state class,
these are the dimensions,
these are their mappers,
these are their units,
these are their invariants,
these are their admissibility tests,
these are their quantization rules.
```

Example:

```json
{
  "grammar_id": "spatial-object-joseph6@v1",
  "grammar_kind": "world_object",
  "axiom_pack_refs": [
    "logic-core@v1",
    "set-theory-zf-fragment@v1",
    "peano-arithmetic@v1",
    "euclidean-geometry@v1",
    "classical-mechanics@v1",
    "kolmogorov-probability@v1"
  ],
  "dimensions": [
    {
      "name": "position",
      "type": "octree_cell",
      "mapper": "octree-cell@v1",
      "unit": "cell_id",
      "invariants": [
        "frame_id_committed",
        "integer_quantized",
        "cell_id_in_range"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "scale",
      "type": "scale_level",
      "mapper": "scale-level@v1",
      "invariants": [
        "level_min_le_level_le_level_max"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "rotation",
      "type": "orientation_cell",
      "mapper": "euler-ypr@v1",
      "invariants": [
        "orientation_quantized",
        "axis_order_committed"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "material",
      "type": "symbol_table_index",
      "mapper": "material-table@v1",
      "invariants": [
        "material_table_nonempty",
        "material_index_in_range"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "relation_seed",
      "type": "raw_relation_entropy",
      "mapper": "passthrough-hex@v1",
      "invariants": [
        "reserved_for_relation_kernel"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "behavior",
      "type": "symbol_table_index",
      "mapper": "behavior-table@v1",
      "invariants": [
        "behavior_table_nonempty",
        "behavior_index_in_range"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
```

This is Joseph6 as a grammar.

## 6.2 How axioms decide the number of dimensions

The selector should solve:

```text
G* = argmin_G [
    residual(G; benchmark_tasks)
  + λ_complexity · complexity(G)
  + λ_cost · compute_cost(G)
  + λ_privacy · privacy_cost(G)
  + λ_instability · version_drift_risk(G)
]
```

Subject to:

```text
logic invariants pass
set/type invariants pass
arithmetic/counting invariants pass
geometry/frame invariants pass
temporal invariants pass
physics constraints pass, if the object class claims physical grounding
privacy constraints pass
KAT replay passes
canonicalization is deterministic
no continuous tensor enters proof path
```

This is the correct implementation of “let it decide how many.”

The system does not “feel” how many dimensions it wants. It selects the minimal sufficient state basis under formal constraints.

---

# 7. How geometry emerges naturally

Geometry emerges when the grammar contains:

```text
frame_id
grid type
origin commitment
spatial level
cell id
transform rules
metric/adjacency rules
```

For example, the v7-W docs already recommend hierarchical grids: S2-style cells for geographic frames, octree levels for local object-fixed frames, and quadtree levels for 2D floor/image-plane frames. The manifest declares grid type, frame, origin commitment, `level_min`, `level_max`, and extent. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

Once that is in the grammar, geometry is not latent. It becomes enumerable:

```text
cell_count(level) = 8^level     for octree
cell_count(level) = 4^level     for quadtree
neighbors(cell)   = deterministic adjacency function
parent(cell)      = floor(cell / branching_factor)
children(cell)    = deterministic child set
```

So geometry emerges as:

```text
finite cell algebra + frame transforms + metric constraints
```

not as a neural embedding.

---

# 8. How counting emerges naturally

Counting emerges because every canonical domain is finite or explicitly quantized.

For an octree grammar:

```text
number_of_cells(level) = 8^level = 2^(3level)
```

For a material table:

```text
number_of_materials = len(materials)
```

For behavior codes:

```text
number_of_behaviors = len(behaviors)
```

For a full Joseph6 object grammar:

```text
state_count ≈
    position_cells(level)
  × scale_levels
  × rotation_bins
  × material_count
  × relation_seed_space
  × behavior_count
```

This directly connects `π*_w_object` to existing `combinatorics@v1`. The current π* library already includes a pure-integer counting kernel and math kernels for exact rational arithmetic, symbolic algebra, calculus, linear algebra, sampled functions, and time-series quantization. ([Arborist API Reference][2])

So the AGI substrate route is:

```text
world grammar → finite state space → combinatorics kernel → countable search/sampling → falsifiable transitions
```

Counting is not external. It is induced by the canonical grammar.

---

# 9. How temporal domain emerges naturally

The v7-W docs already define temporal canonicalization. Single-agent deployments can use wall-clock ticks with a declared epoch and Δt, while multi-agent deployments can use Lamport or vector clocks with tie-breaking. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

So the AnchorN grammar should reserve temporal dimensions only when needed.

Examples:

For a static object:

```text
dimensions:
    position
    scale
    rotation
    material
```

For an observation:

```text
dimensions:
    observer_agent
    observed_at_time
    frame_id
    object_id
    confidence
```

For an agent trace:

```text
dimensions:
    t_i
    pose_i
    attention_target_i
    transition_reason_i
```

Temporal emergence is then:

```text
clock manifest + discrete ticks + event transition grammar
```

And causality becomes testable:

```text
state_t
+ committed transform/event
→ state_t+1
```

The v7-W theorem section already states that a commitment chain is causally complete only if every transition between consecutive observations is justified by a committed transform or event. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

#000070 should be the first object-state piece. Later tickets must add event and transition kernels.

---

# 10. How mathematics and physics enter without breaking determinism

Mathematics/physics should enter as **axiom packs and invariant validators**, not as free-form model beliefs.

## 10.1 AxiomPack

```json
{
  "axiom_pack_id": "classical-rigid-body@v1",
  "axioms": [
    "integer_grid_state@v1",
    "frame_transform_composition@v1",
    "positive_extent@v1",
    "bounded_velocity@v1",
    "mass_nonnegative@v1",
    "causal_transition_requires_event_or_transform@v1"
  ],
  "validators": [
    "validate_integer_quantization",
    "validate_frame_transform",
    "validate_causal_transition",
    "validate_energy_bound_optional"
  ]
}
```

## 10.2 Deterministic validation

Every accepted grammar must pass:

```text
type check
range check
unit check
frame check
clock check
countability check
privacy check
KAT replay
bench fixture replay
```

Physics enters as constraints:

```text
no silent teleportation
no uncommitted frame transform
bounded velocity unless event explains discontinuity
causal gap flagged
collision/occlusion predicates require relation kernel
```

That is enough to instantiate a physics-aware state-space without pretending to solve all physics.

---

# 11. Why this is AGI-relevant

A normal LLM stack does this:

```text
pixels/text → embedding → answer
```

The state is implicit. The model may “know” geometry, but cannot expose a deterministic, replayable world-state.

Your stack should do this:

```text
input / observation
→ canonical projection π*
→ committed state object
→ relation/event/trace update
→ falsification
→ accepted state transition
→ memory/root update
→ recursive improvement
```

#000070 is the first executable piece of:

```text
world-state as committed substrate
```

That matters because AGI in your true sense is better modeled as accepted state transition, not output generation.

A system becomes more AGI-like when it can:

```text
represent its state
commit its state
transform its state
falsify illegal transitions
repair or quarantine bad transitions
compare candidate futures
choose lower-residual updates
preserve provenance across time
```

#000070 gives the world-object state primitive. It does not finish AGI, but it is foundational.

---

# 12. Corrected #000070 specification

## 12.1 Purpose

```text
Implement a deterministic world-object canonicalization kernel that maps:

    hard_hash_32
    spatial_anchor_seed
    WorldDimensionGrammar
    world manifest

to:

    canonical world-object bytes
    world_object_hash

using generic AnchorN, with Joseph6 as the first default grammar.
```

## 12.2 Non-purpose

```text
Not a semantic truth verifier.
Not a SLAM stack.
Not a relation kernel.
Not an event kernel.
Not a place kernel.
Not an agent_trace kernel.
Not a learned world model.
Not a runtime LLM ontology selector.
```

## 12.3 Phase 1 deliverable

```text
Generic AnchorN split.
Joseph6 grammar.
π*_w_object canonicalizer.
KATs.
Tests.
Docs amendment.
No SQL.
No new audit_mode.
No verifier_policy_hash change.
```

---

# 13. Corrected implementation layout

The public π* docs say new π* modules should be registry-addressable by `name@version`, and behaviorally immutable once registered. ([Arborist API Reference][2])

Recommended package split:

```text
arborist/substrate/spatial_anchor.py
    AnchorN
    split_anchor_n()
    SPATIAL_ANCHOR_VERSION
    PLACEHOLDER_SPATIAL_SEED

arborist/world/grammar.py
    WorldDimensionGrammar
    canonical_grammar_bytes()
    grammar_hash()
    validate_grammar()

arborist/world/pi_star/object.py
    derive_world_object_record()
    mappers:
        map_octree_position()
        map_scale_level()
        map_rotation_euler_ypr()
        map_symbol_table_index()
        map_passthrough_hex()

arborist/pi_star/spatial_anchor_object.py
    registered π* adapter:
        name = "spatial-anchor-object"
        version = "v1"
        canonicalize(raw: bytes) -> bytes

bench/fixtures/spatial-anchor-object/known-answer-tests.jsonl

tests/test_spatial_anchor.py
tests/test_world_dimension_grammar.py
tests/test_pi_star_spatial_anchor_object.py
```

This preserves:

```text
arborist/pi_star/
    registry-facing canonicalizer

arborist/world/
    v7-W domain logic
```

---

# 14. AnchorN pseudocode

```python
from __future__ import annotations

import hmac
import hashlib
from dataclasses import dataclass
from typing import Tuple


SPATIAL_ANCHOR_VERSION = "spatial-anchor-n@v1-hmac-sha512-le"


@dataclass(frozen=True)
class AnchorN:
    version: str
    regions: Tuple[bytes, ...]


def _require_bytes_32(name: str, value: bytes) -> None:
    if not isinstance(value, bytes):
        raise TypeError(f"{name} must be bytes")
    if len(value) != 32:
        raise ValueError(f"{name} must be exactly 32 bytes")


def _expand_hmac_sha512(seed: bytes, message: bytes, out_len: int) -> bytes:
    out = bytearray()
    counter = 0
    while len(out) < out_len:
        ctr = counter.to_bytes(4, "little")
        out.extend(hmac.new(seed, message + ctr, hashlib.sha512).digest())
        counter += 1
    return bytes(out[:out_len])


def split_anchor_n(
    hard_hash_32: bytes,
    *,
    seed: bytes,
    n_regions: int,
) -> AnchorN:
    _require_bytes_32("hard_hash_32", hard_hash_32)
    _require_bytes_32("seed", seed)

    if not isinstance(n_regions, int):
        raise TypeError("n_regions must be int")
    if n_regions <= 0:
        raise ValueError("n_regions must be positive")
    if n_regions > 1024:
        raise ValueError("n_regions too large for v1 policy cap")

    raw = _expand_hmac_sha512(seed, hard_hash_32, 32 * n_regions)
    regions = tuple(raw[i:i + 32] for i in range(0, 32 * n_regions, 32))

    return AnchorN(
        version=SPATIAL_ANCHOR_VERSION,
        regions=regions,
    )
```

Policy cap `n_regions <= 1024` is arbitrary but useful. It prevents denial-of-service by a malicious manifest declaring millions of dimensions.

---

# 15. Corrected Joseph6 grammar

```python
JOSEPH6_GRAMMAR = {
    "grammar_id": "spatial-object-joseph6@v1",
    "grammar_kind": "world_object",
    "dimensions": [
        {
            "name": "position",
            "mapper": "octree-cell@v1",
            "source_region": 0,
        },
        {
            "name": "scale",
            "mapper": "scale-level@v1",
            "source_region": 1,
        },
        {
            "name": "rotation",
            "mapper": "euler-ypr@v1",
            "source_region": 2,
        },
        {
            "name": "material",
            "mapper": "symbol-table-index@v1",
            "source_region": 3,
            "table": "materials",
        },
        {
            "name": "relation_seed",
            "mapper": "passthrough-hex@v1",
            "source_region": 4,
            "reserved_for": "pi_w_relation",
        },
        {
            "name": "behavior",
            "mapper": "symbol-table-index@v1",
            "source_region": 5,
            "table": "behaviors",
        }
    ]
}
```

This preserves Joseph6 while making the substrate extensible.

---

# 16. Critical mapper correction: H₁ must use uint256, not uint64

Earlier I identified a real implementation bug risk: if H₁ only reads the first 8 bytes, it fails for v7-W’s documented `level_max = 24` octree example. The docs show `level_max: 24`; an octree at level 24 has `8^24 = 2^72` cells, which cannot be fully addressed by a 64-bit integer. ([Arborist API Reference][1])

Correct:

```python
def uint256_le(region: bytes) -> int:
    if len(region) != 32:
        raise ValueError("region must be 32 bytes")
    return int.from_bytes(region, "little")


def map_octree_cell(region: bytes, *, level: int) -> int:
    if level < 0:
        raise ValueError("level must be nonnegative")
    if 3 * level > 256:
        raise ValueError("octree level too deep for 256-bit region")
    cells = 1 << (3 * level)
    return uint256_le(region) % cells
```

Also fix composition:

```text
H₂ should select scale_level first.
H₁ should map position at that selected scale_level.
```

So:

```python
scale_level = map_scale_level(H2, level_min, level_max)
cell_id = map_octree_cell(H1, level=scale_level)
```

This is more coherent than mapping H₁ at `level_max` while separately outputting a scale level.

---

# 17. Rotation: do not overclaim SO(3)

If Phase 1 uses three integer bins, call it:

```text
euler-ypr@v1
```

not:

```text
SO(3) proof
integer quaternion grid
```

Manifest:

```json
{
  "rotation": {
    "mapper": "euler-ypr@v1",
    "axis_order": "yaw_pitch_roll",
    "delta_milli_radians": 1,
    "range": "mod_2pi"
  }
}
```

Future ticket:

```text
spatial-anchor-so3-codebook@v1
```

That future grammar can handle:

```text
quaternion normalization
q ≡ -q equivalence
uniform-ish SO(3) cell codebook
codebook_hash
```

Do not put that complexity in #000070 Phase 1.

---

# 18. Canonical object output

Every output must include version and grammar identity.

```json
{
  "pi_star_ref": "spatial-anchor-object@v1",
  "anchor_version": "spatial-anchor-n@v1-hmac-sha512-le",
  "grammar_id": "spatial-object-joseph6@v1",
  "grammar_hash": "sha256:...",
  "axiom_pack_hash": "sha256:...",
  "manifest_hash": "sha256:...",
  "seed_hash": "sha256:...",
  "hard_hash_hex": "...",

  "fields": {
    "position": {
      "kind": "octree_cell",
      "level": 18,
      "cell_id": "123456789"
    },
    "scale": {
      "level": 18
    },
    "rotation": {
      "kind": "euler-ypr@v1",
      "bins": [123, 456, 789]
    },
    "material": {
      "table": "materials",
      "index": 4,
      "value": "metal"
    },
    "relation_seed": {
      "hex": "..."
    },
    "behavior": {
      "table": "behaviors",
      "index": 2,
      "value": "static"
    }
  }
}
```

Canonical bytes:

```python
json.dumps(record, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"), ensure_ascii=False).encode("utf-8")
```

Then:

```text
world_object_hash = SHA256(canonical_bytes)
```

---

# 19. Privacy and safety

Spatial commitments can leak sensitive state. Therefore:

```text
privacy.class is mandatory.
No default to public.
```

Phase 1:

```text
privacy.class == public:
    allow.

privacy.class == aggregated_only:
    raise NotImplementedError or emit non-exportable local object only.

privacy.class == ZK_with_selective_disclosure:
    raise NotImplementedError pending #000016.

privacy.class missing:
    fail closed.
```

This preserves future private/ZK work without pretending Phase 1 solves it.

---

# 20. Hash / cache / verifier-policy discipline

For #000070 Phase 1:

```text
canonicalization_version:
    must include spatial-anchor-object@v1.

governance_policy_hash:
    must include active world grammar hash / manifest hash if used during query/agent execution.

schema_version:
    unchanged, because no SQL in Phase 1.

verifier_policy_hash:
    unchanged, because this is not a verifier rule.

audit_mode:
    unchanged.
```

If later world-state commitments become a verifier method, that is a different ticket and `verifier_policy_hash` must move.

---

# 21. Tests and KATs

Minimum KAT rows:

```text
1. all-zero hard_hash
2. all-ff hard_hash
3. alternating 00ff hard_hash
4. fixed random hard_hash
5. one-bit flip from row 4
6. same hard_hash, different seed
7. same seed, different Joseph6 material table order
8. same seed, different level_max
9. level_max=24 regression proving uint256 position mapping
10. variable AnchorN grammar with N=8
```

Each KAT row pins:

```text
anchor_version
pi_star_ref
grammar_hash
manifest_hash
seed_hash
hard_hash_hex
N
regions_hex[]
field outputs
canonical_output_sha256
```

Required tests:

```text
test_split_anchor_n_requires_32_byte_hash
test_split_anchor_n_requires_32_byte_seed
test_split_anchor_n_rejects_nonpositive_n
test_split_anchor_n_policy_cap
test_split_anchor_n_deterministic
test_split_anchor_n_changes_with_seed
test_split_anchor_n_changes_with_hash
test_joseph6_is_wrapper_over_anchor_n
test_position_uses_uint256_not_uint64_level24
test_h2_scale_drives_h1_position_level
test_rotation_mapper_declared_euler_not_so3
test_material_table_nonempty
test_behavior_table_nonempty
test_manifest_requires_privacy_class
test_non_public_privacy_fails_closed_phase1
test_canonical_output_includes_grammar_hash
test_canonical_output_includes_manifest_hash
test_canonical_output_includes_axiom_pack_hash
test_registered_pi_star_exists
test_pi_star_returns_bytes
test_no_audit_mode_change
test_no_verifier_policy_hash_change
test_no_sql_write
```

---

# 22. Relationship to #000071

#000070 and #000071 must stay separate.

```text
#000070:
    one world, one grammar, one object-state canonicalization.

#000071:
    bridge grammar between worlds/chains.
```

AnchorN tells you how to instantiate state inside a world.

World-bridge grammar tells you whether two worlds can exchange, translate, quarantine, or reject each other’s states.

Do not merge them.

---

# 23. Roadmap to AGI substrate

## Phase 1 — AnchorN + Joseph6

Deliver:

```text
generic AnchorN
Joseph6 default grammar
π*_w_object canonicalizer
KATs
no SQL
no verifier changes
```

AGI value:

```text
first deterministic world-object state primitive
```

## Phase 2 — WorldDimensionGrammar

Deliver:

```text
grammar manifest
grammar_hash
axiom_pack_hash
dimension registry
mapper registry
grammar validators
```

AGI value:

```text
state-space dimensionality becomes explicit, reproducible, evolvable
```

## Phase 3 — AxiomPack and physics validators

Deliver:

```text
logic/set/arithmetic/geometry/time/physics axiom packs
deterministic invariant checks
minimal sufficient dimension selector
```

AGI value:

```text
math and physics constrain world-state, rather than merely appearing in text
```

## Phase 4 — Relation kernel

Deliver:

```text
π*_w_relation
relation_seed consumption
ordered/symmetric relation rules
predicate whitelist
relation confidence
time_window
```

AGI value:

```text
geometry becomes relational; objects become graph nodes
```

## Phase 5 — Event kernel

Deliver:

```text
π*_w_event
state_t + event → state_t+1
causal completeness checks
```

AGI value:

```text
temporal state transitions become falsifiable
```

## Phase 6 — Place and agent_trace kernels

Deliver:

```text
π*_w_place
π*_w_agent_trace
trace quantization
frame transforms
Lamport/vector clock support
```

AGI value:

```text
persistent agent state, navigation, spatial memory
```

## Phase 7 — MemoryRoot / SelfModel integration

Deliver:

```text
world_state_root
memory_root integration
SelfModel state links
state transition DAG
```

AGI value:

```text
the system can know what it has seen, where, when, and under what commitments
```

## Phase 8 — v8 selection / consensus

Deliver:

```text
validators compare world transitions
ForkScore consumes world-state residuals
challenge protocol catches illegal transitions
```

AGI value:

```text
recursive self-improvement becomes benchmark-governed and consensus-filtered
```

## Phase 9 — recursive improvement loop

Loop:

```text
observe
→ canonicalize
→ commit
→ predict next state
→ compare with future observation
→ falsify residual
→ update grammar/mapper candidate
→ benchmark
→ accept only if residual decreases without proof-path regression
```

This is the actual AGI route:

```text
not “model gets smarter by outputting more text”
but “system improves by reducing state-transition residual under provenance.”
```

---

# 24. How this instantiates state-space

The state-space is:

```text
Ω_t = (
    ObjectRoot_t,
    RelationRoot_t,
    EventRoot_t,
    PlaceRoot_t,
    AgentTraceRoot_t,
    MemoryRoot_t,
    SelfModelRoot_t,
    PolicyRoot_t,
    GrammarRoot_t,
    AxiomPackRoot_t
)
```

Transition:

```text
Ω_{t+1} = T(Ω_t, Observation_t, Action_t, Event_t, Grammar_t)
```

Accepted only if:

```text
canonicalization passes
frame/time transforms are committed
physics/logic invariants pass
falsification residual within bound
audit/provenance roots update deterministically
```

This lets domains emerge:

```text
counting:
    finite state enumeration from quantized grammar.

geometry:
    grid cells, frames, transforms, adjacency, containment.

time:
    clock ticks, Lamport/vector order, time windows.

logic:
    relations, predicates, constraints, truthtables.

math:
    combinatorics, algebra, linear transforms, calculus kernels for dynamics.

physics:
    transition invariants, causality, bounded velocity/energy constraints.

agency:
    action DAG + state transition + SelfModel update.
```

That is the substrate-level AGI move.

---

# 25. Final corrected ticket text

```text
#000070 — AnchorN and π*_w_object: deterministic world-object state canonicalization

Status:
    GO after ticket rewrite.

Purpose:
    Implement the first executable v7-W world-object canonicalization kernel.
    The kernel maps a hard hash, spatial anchor seed, and frozen world grammar
    into canonical world-object bytes.

Core correction:
    The substrate primitive is AnchorN, not Anchor6.
    Joseph6 is the first registered WorldDimensionGrammar, not the final ontology.

Inputs:
    hard_hash_32
    spatial_anchor_seed
    WorldDimensionGrammar
    world manifest

Outputs:
    canonical world-object bytes
    world_object_hash
    object record with grammar_hash, axiom_pack_hash, manifest_hash, seed_hash

Phase 1:
    split_anchor_n()
    Joseph6 grammar
    spatial-anchor-object@v1 π*
    KATs and tests
    docs amendment

Out of scope:
    semantic verifier warrant
    new audit_mode
    SQL persistence
    relation/event/place/agent_trace
    runtime LLM-selected dimensionality

Hard constraints:
    deterministic
    quantized integer state only
    no continuous tensor in proof path
    no LLM-as-judge
    no hidden soft transform
    no in-place version mutation
    fail closed on missing privacy.class
```

---

# 26. Final compressed answer

```text
The earlier H₁..H₆ design is a good first grammar, but it should not be the substrate limit.

Correct architecture:

    AnchorN + WorldDimensionGrammar.

Joseph6 remains the first default grammar:

    position
    scale
    rotation
    material
    relation_seed
    behavior

But the system must support N dimensions selected by frozen, axiom-constrained grammars.

Math/physics axioms should not dynamically mutate the proof path.
They should generate/validate a grammar.
Once accepted, that grammar is canonicalized, hashed, versioned, KAT-tested,
and used deterministically.

This gives the AGI path:

    quantized state-space
    finite counting
    grid/frame geometry
    temporal clocks
    relation/event transitions
    causal completeness
    recursive falsification
    benchmark-governed self-improvement

Final decision:

    rewrite #000070 around AnchorN;
    implement Joseph6 as Phase 1;
    defer axiom-guided grammar selection to Phase 2/3;
    preserve no-audit-mode/no-verifier-policy-change discipline;
    use the resulting world-object kernel as the first executable v7-W state-space primitive.
```

The core insight:

```text
Six fixed seeds make a demo.
AnchorN plus axiom-frozen grammar makes a substrate.
```

[1]: https://arborist.unturf.com/en/latest/merkle-agi-v7w-spatial-temporal.html "Merkle-AGI v7-W — Spatial-Temporal Substrate — Arborist API Reference"
[2]: https://arborist.unturf.com/en/latest/pi-star.html "π* domain library — Arborist API Reference"
[3]: https://arborist.unturf.com/en/latest/api/qa.html "Q&A Pipeline: question → answer → verify → cache — Arborist API Reference"
[4]: https://arborist.unturf.com/en/latest/concepts.html "Concepts — Arborist API Reference"

---
# IMPORTANT
Correct — **we should not fix the six seeds as the architecture**.

My prior wording should be tightened. The correct position is:

```text
Reject fixed H₁..H₆ as ontology.
Keep H₁..H₆ only as an optional legacy / compatibility profile, not the core design.
Core design = emergent AnchorN from axiom-governed WorldDimensionGrammar.
```

So the corrected #000070 principle is:

```text
Do not start with:
    H₁ = position
    H₂ = scale
    H₃ = rotation
    H₄ = material
    H₅ = relation
    H₆ = behavior

Start with:
    AxiomPack + WorldClass + Constraints + Bench/Falsifiers
        → derive minimal sufficient DimensionGrammar G*
        → N = |G*.dimensions|
        → split hash into AnchorN regions
        → map each region through typed mappers
        → canonical world-state object
```

# 1. The corrected architecture

The actual substrate primitive should be:

```text
AnchorN(G)
```

not:

```text
Anchor6
```

Where:

```text
G = frozen WorldDimensionGrammar
N = number of dimensions required by G
```

So the object kernel becomes:

```text
hard_hash_32
+ spatial_anchor_seed
+ axiom_pack_hash
+ world_class
+ constraint_set
+ selected_dimension_grammar_hash
→ AnchorN
→ canonical state record
```

The six-seed form is demoted to:

```text
joseph6@legacy_or_example
```

not:

```text
default ontology
```

Even calling it “default” may be too strong if the goal is natural emergence. Better:

```text
Joseph6 = reference fixture / baseline grammar / backward-compatible example.
```

# 2. What “emerge naturally” means without losing determinism

“Emerge naturally” cannot mean the model dynamically invents dimensions each run. That would destroy reproducibility.

It should mean:

```text
The dimension basis is not hand-fixed.
It is selected by deterministic constraint optimization over candidate grammars.
Once selected, it is frozen, hashed, and replayable.
```

Formal version:

```text
Given:
    A = axiom pack
    W = world class
    C = constraints
    B = benchmark/falsifier suite
    Γ = candidate dimension grammars

Select:
    G* = argmin_G∈Γ [
        residual(G; B)
      + λ₁ complexity(G)
      + λ₂ compute_cost(G)
      + λ₃ privacy_cost(G)
      + λ₄ instability_cost(G)
    ]

Subject to:
    logic invariants pass
    arithmetic/counting invariants pass
    geometry/frame invariants pass
    temporal invariants pass
    physics constraints pass where applicable
    KAT replay passes
    canonicalization is deterministic
```

Then:

```text
N = |G*.dimensions|
```

Only after this do we split:

```text
AnchorN = HMAC_expand(seed, hard_hash, 32N)
```

That is the distinction.

# 3. What #000070 should say now

Replace the ticket’s core with:

```text
#000070 — Axiom-governed AnchorN world-object canonicalization

Purpose:
    Implement the generic substrate for deterministic world-state instantiation.

Core:
    Do not fix six fields.
    Implement AnchorN driven by a frozen WorldDimensionGrammar.

Inputs:
    hard_hash_32
    spatial_anchor_seed
    axiom_pack_hash
    world_class
    constraint_set
    selected_dimension_grammar

Output:
    canonical world-state record
    world_state_hash

Phase 1:
    implement AnchorN
    implement WorldDimensionGrammar schema
    implement deterministic grammar validation
    implement one or more test grammars only as fixtures

Explicit non-goal:
    Do not promote Joseph6 as ontology.
```

# 4. What happens to Joseph6?

Joseph6 can remain only as:

```text
test fixture
example grammar
compatibility profile
sanity-check baseline
```

Not:

```text
the primitive
the ontology
the mandatory default
the AGI path
```

Correct label:

```text
spatial-object-joseph6@fixture-v1
```

or:

```text
spatial-object-sixslot-baseline@v1
```

Not:

```text
spatial-anchor-object@v1
```

because that name implies six-slot is the object grammar.

Better naming:

```text
anchor-n@v1
world-dimension-grammar@v1
world-object-canonicalizer@v1
sixslot-baseline-grammar@v1
```

# 5. Corrected implementation roadmap

## Phase 1 — generic substrate only

Implement:

```text
split_anchor_n(hash, seed, n)
WorldDimensionGrammar
grammar_hash
axiom_pack_hash
dimension registry
mapper registry
canonical output schema
KATs for N = 1, 2, 6, 8, 16
```

Do **not** hard-code:

```text
position
scale
rotation
material
relation
behavior
```

except inside a fixture grammar.

## Phase 2 — axiom/physics grammar selector

Implement:

```text
candidate grammar generator
constraint validator
residual scorer
minimal sufficient basis selector
grammar freezing
```

Candidate dimensions might include:

```text
position
orientation
scale
velocity
angular_velocity
mass
material
field_value
relation_boundary
temporal_tick
causal_event
agent_frame
confidence
energy_bound
```

The system decides which are needed for a world class.

## Phase 3 — emergent state-space bench

Bench asks:

```text
Can this grammar support counting?
Can it support adjacency?
Can it support frame transforms?
Can it support temporal ordering?
Can it support causal transitions?
Can it support falsification of impossible transitions?
```

The grammar survives only if it passes.

## Phase 4 — relation/event/place/agent traces

Only after object grammar emerges do we add:

```text
π*_w_relation
π*_w_event
π*_w_place
π*_w_agent_trace
```

# 6. The AGI substrate version

The corrected AGI state equation is:

```text
Ω_t = (
    GrammarRoot_t,
    AxiomPackRoot_t,
    ObjectRoot_t,
    RelationRoot_t,
    EventRoot_t,
    PlaceRoot_t,
    AgentTraceRoot_t,
    MemoryRoot_t,
    SelfModelRoot_t,
    PolicyRoot_t
)
```

Transition:

```text
Ω_{t+1} = T(Ω_t, Observation_t, Action_t, Falsifier_t)
```

Accepted only if:

```text
selected grammar is frozen
canonicalization passes
geometry/counting/time invariants pass
physics constraints pass where applicable
Merkle roots update deterministically
residual decreases or stays within bound
```

This is where geometry/counting/time emerge:

```text
counting:
    from finite quantized dimensions and state enumeration.

geometry:
    from selected spatial dimensions, adjacency, frame transforms.

time:
    from selected temporal dimensions, clocks, event order.

logic:
    from relation/event predicates and truthtables.

physics:
    from transition constraints and conservation/bound validators.
```

# 7. Final correction to my earlier answer

Earlier I said:

```text
Implement Joseph6 as Phase 1.
```

Corrected:

```text
Implement AnchorN as Phase 1.
Use Joseph6 only as a test fixture or example grammar.
Do not make Joseph6 the first canonical object ontology.
```

Even more precise:

```text
The first canonical object ontology should be whatever the
WorldDimensionGrammar selector validates under the chosen axiom pack
and benchmark constraints.

Until that selector exists, Joseph6 must be explicitly marked:
    non-authoritative baseline fixture.
```

# 8. Final answer

You are right to push back.

```text
We are rejecting fixed six seeds as the substrate.
We are not rejecting the ability to test a six-slot fixture.
```

The corrected #000070 should be:

```text
AnchorN first.
Axiom-governed WorldDimensionGrammar second.
Emergent N from constraint optimization.
Joseph6 only as fixture/baseline, not ontology.
```

The one-line correction:

```text
Six fixed seeds make a demo; AnchorN with axiom-selected grammar makes the AGI substrate.
```
