{"_meta": {"battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "task_count": 50, "notes": "Operation/observation chains. Final-step expected_delta must appear in aggregated observation feed; tests integration of observations into downstream state. Phase 1c (2026-05-09): expanded 10→30. Phase 1d (2026-05-09): expanded 30→50."}}
{"id":"5f-fb-001","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"claim X is stale"},{"operation":"update_memory","observation":"memory branch marks X stale"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"X appears in stale set","expected_delta":"X appears in stale set"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-002","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"new fact alpha learned"},{"operation":"update_memory","observation":"memory branch records alpha"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"alpha appears in current memory","expected_delta":"alpha appears in current memory"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-003","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"verifier flagged warrant_missing"},{"operation":"falsify","observation":"providence record marked stale"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"stale record appears in falsification log","expected_delta":"stale record appears in falsification log"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-004","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"baseline observed"},{"operation":"observe","observation":"motif title_mismatch occurred"},{"operation":"update_memory","observation":"motif counter incremented","expected_delta":"motif counter incremented"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-005","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"capability claim falsified"},{"operation":"selfmodel_update","observation":"selfmodel state flipped to falsified"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"falsified state recorded in selfmodel_records","expected_delta":"falsified state recorded in selfmodel_records"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-006","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"stale data point"},{"operation":"no_action","observation":"nothing changed"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"unrelated content","expected_delta":"data point appears in stale set"}],"expected":"fail"}
{"id":"5f-fb-007","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"empty"},{"operation":"observe","observation":"event delta_event happened"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"delta_event recorded","expected_delta":"delta_event recorded"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-008","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"correction applied to claim Q1"},{"operation":"update_memory","observation":"correction logged"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"corrected Q1 visible","expected_delta":"corrected Q1 visible"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-009","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"silent failure unobserved"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"chain produced no signal","expected_delta":"silent failure unobserved"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id":"5f-fb-010","battery":"5f","sub_battery":"feedback-loop","version":"v1","carrier":"memory_snapshot","domain":"memory_root","pi_star_ref":"pi_memory_v1","chain":[{"operation":"observe","observation":"ingest succeeded"},{"operation":"update_memory","observation":"ingest event in audit chain"},{"operation":"snapshot","observation":"ingest visible at high water mark","expected_delta":"ingest visible at high water mark"}],"expected":"pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-011", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "claim Y is stale"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch marks Y stale"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "Y appears in stale set", "expected_delta": "Y appears in stale set"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-012", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "new fact gamma learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records gamma"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "gamma in current memory", "expected_delta": "gamma in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-013", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact Z contradicts memory"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch invalidates Z's prior"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "Z's prior absent from current memory", "expected_delta": "Z's prior absent from current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-014", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "answer A scored STRICT"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "STRICT count for A increments"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "STRICT count up by 1", "expected_delta": "STRICT count up by 1"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-015", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "branch B current"}, {"operation": "observe", "observation": "B's claim falsified"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "B marked stale"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "B no longer in live set", "expected_delta": "B no longer in live set"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-016", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "shard 003 received update"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "shard 003 high-water bumped"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "high-water shows new value", "expected_delta": "high-water shows new value"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-017", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "memory_root R0"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "R0 → R1 transition"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "memory_root R1", "expected_delta": "memory_root R1"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-018", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "ForkScore parent baseline"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "baseline pinned"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "baseline visible to scorer", "expected_delta": "baseline visible to scorer"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-019", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact delta seen"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory updated for unrelated thing"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "no mention of delta", "expected_delta": "delta visible in snapshot"}], "expected": "fail"}
{"id": "5f-fb-020", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "stale set s0"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "tried to update but failed"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "stale set unchanged", "expected_delta": "expected delta unrealized"}], "expected": "fail"}
{"id": "5f-fb-021", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "claim Y is stale"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch marks Y stale"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "Y appears in stale set", "expected_delta": "Y appears in stale set"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-022", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "new fact gamma learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records gamma"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "gamma in current memory", "expected_delta": "gamma in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-023", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact Z contradicts memory"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch invalidates Z's prior"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "Z's prior absent from current memory", "expected_delta": "Z's prior absent from current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-024", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "answer A scored STRICT"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "STRICT count for A increments"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "STRICT count up by 1", "expected_delta": "STRICT count up by 1"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-025", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "branch B current"}, {"operation": "observe", "observation": "B's claim falsified"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "B marked stale"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "B no longer in live set", "expected_delta": "B no longer in live set"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-026", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "shard 003 received update"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "shard 003 high-water bumped"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "high-water shows new value", "expected_delta": "high-water shows new value"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-027", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "memory_root R0"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "R0 → R1 transition"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "memory_root R1", "expected_delta": "memory_root R1"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-028", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "ForkScore parent baseline"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "baseline pinned"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "baseline visible to scorer", "expected_delta": "baseline visible to scorer"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-029", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact delta seen"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory updated for unrelated thing"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "no mention of delta", "expected_delta": "delta visible in snapshot"}], "expected": "fail"}
{"id": "5f-fb-030", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "stale set s0"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "tried to update but failed"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "stale set unchanged", "expected_delta": "expected delta unrealized"}], "expected": "fail"}
{"id": "5f-fb-031", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-31 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-31"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-31 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-31 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-032", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-32 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-32"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-32 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-32 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-033", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-33 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-33"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-33 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-33 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-034", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-34 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-34"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-34 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-34 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-035", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-35 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-35"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-35 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-35 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-036", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-36 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-36"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-36 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-36 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-037", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-37 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-37"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-37 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-37 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-038", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-38 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-38"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-38 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-38 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-039", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-39 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-39"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-39 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-39 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-040", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-40 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-40"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-40 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-40 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-041", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-41 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-41"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-41 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-41 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-042", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-42 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-42"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-42 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-42 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-043", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-43 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-43"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-43 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-43 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-044", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-44 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-44"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-44 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-44 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-045", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-45 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-45"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-45 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-45 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-046", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-46 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-46"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-46 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-46 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-047", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-47 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-47"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-47 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-47 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-048", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-48 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-48"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-48 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-48 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-049", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-49 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-49"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-49 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-49 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
{"id": "5f-fb-050", "battery": "5f", "sub_battery": "feedback-loop", "version": "v1", "carrier": "memory_snapshot", "domain": "memory_root", "pi_star_ref": "pi_memory_v1", "chain": [{"operation": "observe", "observation": "fact-50 learned"}, {"operation": "update_memory", "observation": "memory branch records fact-50"}, {"operation": "snapshot", "observation": "fact-50 in current memory", "expected_delta": "fact-50 in current memory"}], "expected": "pass"}
